Social Entrepreneurship in India

5 Aug

The major boost in social entrepreneurship was given by the Nobel Prize winner Dr. Mohammad Yunus when his brain-child Grameen bank became successful in helping people lift themselves out of poverty in rural Bangladesh by providing them with credit without requiring collateral. Yunus developed his revolutionary micro-credit system with the belief that it would be a cost-effective and scalable weapon to fight poverty.  It was soon realized that profits can be made along with serving the society, provided you treat profits as a means and not the end result.

The impact of such enterprise largely depend on its successful implementation to those that need it the most, those at the Bottom of the Pyramid. And of course a discussion about the BOP wouldn’t be complete without mention of India; where hundreds of millions critically need a compelling movement in social entrepreneurship to improve their welfare.  There is a natural predilection towards rural areas as 70% of the population lives in the hinterland. Recently, the rural scenario in the country has emerged as a lucrative option for the mainstream economy. Various organizations are viewing rural areas as potential markets, resulting in a gamut of innovative solutions within the social entrepreneurship space that focuses on and emerges from rural areas.

The popularity of SE is growing at a very high pace in India even through the current economic downturn. In the last three years more and more youth are developing interest in this field including those from prestigious Stanford, MIT and Oxford. This new evolving field has also got early venture capitalist interested in funding with many seeking out such enterprises that hold out huge potential. Earlier, organizations solving social problems were often assumed to be idealistic, philanthropic and lacking business acumen or the ability to be entrepreneurial. However, as the social sector has been coming in touch with the private sector, both have begun to realize that just one approach either pure philanthropic or pure capitalist is inadequate to build sustainable institutions.

In recent years, ‘not-for-profit’ has been pushed to the back partly because of responsible lenders and social enterprises are being run more like businesses today. The focus is on enterprising micro groups which want to transform their own, and the community’s, circumstances but can’t access any finance.

Fast company in their March 2010 listed “top 10 by Industry”. And four of the top 10 most innovative companies in India were standalone social enterprises or have socially entrepreneurial initiatives.

In India alone social entrepreneurship space has a countless mixture of models with a one billion thinking structure. One billion thinking requires cost-effective models involving the bottom of the pyramid. The majority of these models are scalable and replicable.

Few for-profit social business models

Enterprise Impact Future Plan
VNL: Makes telecom equipment that helps mobile operators reach rural markets profitably 70 station in Rajasthan Replicating and scaling it worldwide
NARAYAN HOSPITAL- Delivering affordable healthcare to the masses worldwide 5000 bed facility completed in phase 1 Health city with 30,000 bed facility by 2016
A LITTLE WORLD-Empowering micro business through micro banking Customer base crosses 3 million Touch a billion people through innovative technologies
BAREFOOT COLLEGE-solar energy, water, education, health care, rural handicrafts, people’s action, communication, women’s empowerment and wasteland development 1,000 Barefoot experts in 1,000 villages, reaches 500,000 people with basic services such as drinking water, health care, and education 10,00,000 people by the end of 2016
CHILDLINE-Country’s first toll-free tele-helpline for street children in distress 9.6 million calls, 3 million children, 73 cities, 10 years 600 + districts by 2013
BASIX INDIA-Sustainable livelihoods to the rural poor and women Over a million and a half customer
CRAFTS BRIDGE-A bridge between customers worldwide and crafts persons, designers N/A To tap 6 million village people associated with the handicrafts sector
ARVIND EYE HOSPITAL – Eliminating needless blindness by taking its services to rural India In last year alone 2.5 million patients were treated and over 3 lakh surgeries were performed To replicate it in all states of India
COMAT-Empowering rural citizens by creating local
economies and enabling access to information and services
Deliver Citizen records and Government benefits to over 50,000 rural citizens every day 75,000 by the end of 2011
D.LIGHT-High quality solutions for families living
without reliable electricity
10 million 50 million by 2015
IDE INDIA-Providing long-term solutions to poverty, hunger and malnutrition 19 million Ending poverty in the developing world
RANGSUTRA– Sustainable livelihoods for artisans and farmers, by creating top quality hand-made products based on the principles of fair trade Approximate 2500 artisans Employ 5000 by 2015
LIJJAT PAPAD-Women Empowerment 4600 women employed Plans to employ 6000 by 2010
SELCO SOLAR INDIA-Sustainable energy solutions and services to under-served households and businesses. 95,000 villages covered Bring down the cost of solar equipment by 75% by 2012
UNLTD INDIA– Angel investor and incubator for social entrepreneurs Each of the projects has, on average, created 1.6 new jobs in the economy World where individuals take action to bring about positive social change
SKS MICROFINANCE-Small loans without collaterals 5.3 Million Customers Take Micro finance to every village
SUMINTER INDIA – Internationally certified organic agricultural produce Premium crop price to more than 7000 farmers Scale this model nationally
VORTEX ENGINEERING – Rural Solar Powered ATMs 750 ATM One ATM/ Village i.e 6,50,000 ATMs

The other notable change is the involvement of mainstream financial institutions in social entrepreneurship. Various venture capital firms are investing in for-profit entities with social objectives. Interestingly, specialized social investors provide capital, networking, marketing and business expertise to such ventures.

This trend was kick-started in the area of microfinance when Sequoia Capital invested in SKS Microfinance. Social venture funds measure their investments on social, environmental and the traditional financial returns. Acumen fund expects to make an impact on million people with every investment in a five-year time frame.  The fund measures returns in terms of financial, operational (internal processes and systems) and social impact (outcome and output). Output is number of people who are impacted and outcome is how it has affected them. For example, if 1,000 people have had access to clean drinking water, the investors also check if the rate of diarrhea has come down. More heartening is the fact that the mainstream venture capitalists are also recognizing this as a business opportunity. So far, VCs have invested $220 million in 77 social businesses in India. But there hasn’t been a single exit. In conventional commercial ventures, VCs work with a holding period of 3-5 years. In social businesses, the holding period is longer — typically, 6-8 years.

Funds Currently available:

Acumen Fund : It supports sustainable enterprises providing the poor with critical goods and services at an affordable price. Primary focus on healthcare, housing, water, energy and agriculture
Companies invested in: 12
Fund size: $40 million (approx)
 
 
VenturEast: It builds profitable businesses that cater to under-served markets. Focuses on meeting India’s domestic needs (primarily rural and semi-urban markets) by backing early-stage / rapid-growth businesses
Companies invested in Over 50 (including 25 social enterprises)
Fund size $250 million
 
 
 
Oasis Fund: It supports enterprises that develop innovative solutions that provide the poor with better access to critical goods and services. Invests mostly equity, with some debt. Investments generally range between $1 million to $6 million
Companies invested in 4
Fund size $30 million (still raising)
 
 
Song: It supports entrepreneurs in high-growth sectors like education and training, agriculture and food, healthcare, financial services, basic utilities (waste, water, rural telecom, affordable housing, etc) that are aligned with inclusive growth
Companies invested in None
Fund size $17 million
 
 
Aavishkaar India Micro Venture Capital: It creates sustainable change by increasing economic activity at the bottom of the pyramid and boosting the entrepreneurial spirit. Investments to date have focused heavily on the rural and agro technology sectors
Companies invested in 17
Fund size Rs 60 crore (approx $14 million)
 
 
Gray Matters Capital: It invests in the information, communication and technology space to bridge the urban-rural digital gap
Companies invested in 4
Fund size $12 million
 
 
Elevar Equity II: It creates market-based solutions for poverty eradication. Focuses on sectors like healthcare, education and information
Companies invested in 1 (another two in micro-finance ventures)
Fund size $40 million (additional fund-raising on)

The above figures simply state that there is an estimated $100 million (Rs 400 crore) chasing deals in India’s social enterprise space.

But there is a divide between those that have access to mainstream and/or commercial funds and those that rely on personal connections and grants/donations to raise money. The ratio is about 50/50.

Foreign grants: 8%
Domestic grants: 8%
Debt (credit loans): 11%
Government Funding: 3%
Charitable Organization: 5%
Bank Loan: 13%
Loan from Family and friends: 21%
Equity Investors: 21 %
Others: 10%

As per Beyond Profit survey, Forty-five percent of respondents obtained funds from commercial sources whereas 21% of respondents source their funds from personal connections such as family members and friends; another 21% rely on grants and donations from charitable organizations. Arranging finances for a social enterprise in India is still very difficult. And knowing in which sector to finance is even more difficult. In bar diagram mentioned below is a mention of profitable sectors and a trend which clearly states areas to divert funds.

Education: Sector with a track record of profit: The Education sector has shown a marked degree of financial stability and growth potential. There are two key elements. First, the sector represents the highest number of profit-making enterprises (38%) among others, and also has one of the lowest numbers of loss-making entities (24%). Second, the observation says that there is a good growth potential; 38% of education enterprises are breaking even — which means the number of profit-making enterprises in this sector could increase in the coming years.

Health: Sector with large growth potential: Although the sector currently produces a very small number of profit-making entities, it has the lowest percentage (13%) of loss-making enterprises. Most importantly, at 73%, the Health sector has the largest segment of break-even businesses. If/when these enterprises begin to turn a profit, the Health sector could sustain a multitude of successful, profit-making enterprises.

Rural Development: Sector to watch out for future growth: Despite the fact that the largest number of social enterprises are in this field, it is the biggest loss-making sector at the moment. However, Rural Development demonstrated the largest revenue increases last year, so there could be more surprises in store.

There are more enterprises that are loss-making (34%) than those earning a profit (25%). And 41% percent of enterprises are currently breaking even. If you look at the profitability by measure of years in operation, you can clearly see that making profit through social enterprise is no easy task.

It is true that the percentage of loss-making enterprises steadily goes down as the companies get older. But there is virtually no disparity in the number of profit-making entities across age categories. Many enterprises stop making losses as they grow older but do not begin to turn a profit; they merely start breaking even. Surprisingly, even after 11 years or more of operations, the percentage of profit-making enterprises is only 27%.

Social entrepreneurship in India is emerging primarily because of what the government has not been able to do. The government is very keen on promoting social entrepreneurship – not necessarily by funding it or by advising on it or enabling it. What they do do, is not disable it.

For example, in Mumbai alone, non-profit organizations educate more than 250,000 children on a daily basis. The government has not told these organizations not to do it. Whereas in some countries, when someone takes it into their own hands to start a facility for education or healthcare or empowerment, the government often puts in place barriers to prevent this from happening.

Our country does not have a homogenous people or geography, so the impact largely remains regional. With the current economic climate, it is very likely that social needs will increase and, consequently, the number of people committed to addressing them will increase. Definition of social entrepreneurship has changed over time. From corporate philanthropy to non-profit and now to self-sustainability, Social Entrepreneurship has evolved and will keep evolving with time and needs of the world.

Advertisements

15 Responses to “Social Entrepreneurship in India”

  1. Venkat Agarwal August 5, 2010 at 17:15 #

    Aarti
    I believe that one reason that Social Entrepreneurship is such a hit is because of government inability. A word of caution here is that a lot of these organizations turn corrupt over time and thus it should be mandatory for them to register. I believe this already happens, what I do want to understand is how to curb this.
    I must complement you for the overall coverage of the topic the depth with numbers gave me detailed insights in the subject.
    I hope you are successful with your endeavors in involving media for social change in our country.

    • Surya Pratap Deka September 27, 2010 at 20:50 #

      Aarti, wht a pleasure reading your article. A friend of mine and I have an idea of creating high performance inclusive education schools in India. We would love you to discuss the idea with you and would love you to be associated with our website http://www.oneschoolforall.org . waiting to hear form you.
      Surya
      9762539809

  2. Sabarinath August 11, 2010 at 17:56 #

    Great write up, with excellent depth. This is the best article on social entrepreneurship that has covered it from so many different angles.

    Good luck to you in your endeavours.

  3. Nikhil August 21, 2010 at 20:20 #

    Thanks for a brilliant article, aarti! I followed here from pluggd.in .
    The part at the end about the Indian Government helping by not doing anything to stop – is actually very good news.
    To expect governments to take care of all of the problems in a society is to put the powers of a God in the hands of fallible humans. We know how that venture has ended. The profit-centered capitalist system then went on to put those powers into private individuals’ hands, and even that model seems to be collapsing.
    The best bet, in my opinion, is to allow the people help themselves.
    I have observed that we have big heartless profiteering that harms the BOP, only in places where there is some or the other regulation, licenses, rebates, sops or other such artificial barriers or stimuluses.

    Maybe not taking sides, maybe letting go and giving true freedom – swarajya – is what we need to do.
    I can see social entrepreneurship expanding into evermore sectors in the coming years. Hope I can be part of this wave as well.

  4. Balagopal September 20, 2010 at 03:40 #

    Aarti,

    My Google search for “Social Entrepreneurship models India” brought me to Plugged In and eventually here to your Blog. I will next search for the funding agencies you listed.

    My plan along with my daughter is to start a pilot Preschool in a typical rural locale in central Kerala. State-supplied education is crumbling with hordes of students making an exodus to private schools unaided by the government.

    We aim to fill the gap by giving middle and lower middle class families by 1. establishing schools in their own villages and 2. by trimming tuition fees affordable to such families. 3. by giving the best education available in the country where the students by accretion will reach class 12 and qualify for the high school diploma.

    Thanks for the great article and an eye opener. Please work out ways we can work together to make this plan a success. My nest step is top replicate the model and franchise to people committed to deliver quality.

  5. potenzmittel October 25, 2010 at 12:01 #

    This is a really good read for me, Must admit that you are one of the best bloggers I ever saw.Thanks for posting this informative article.

  6. videos divertidos October 31, 2010 at 18:46 #

    Hey really nice website, I noticed your website when doing study on some methods to develop my web log. I was simply inquiring which spam software system you use for comments as I get tons on my site.
    I never comment on blogs, but this one is awesome! Thanks.

  7. 網路攝影機 December 3, 2010 at 22:00 #

    Thanks I finally came to a website where the webmaster knows what they’re talking about. Do you know how many results are in Google when I search.. too many! It’s so irritating having to go through page after page after page, wasting my day away with thousands of owners just copying eachother’s articles… bah. Anyway, thanks for the information anyway, much obliged.

  8. generika apotheke December 3, 2010 at 23:04 #

    Naturally, what a good internet site and informative posts, I’ll add backlink – bookmark this internet site? Regards,
    Reader.

  9. pc spiele December 4, 2010 at 01:05 #

    There is clearly a whole lot to know about this. I believe you made some very good points in Features also.
    Keep operating , good career!

  10. cevon July 21, 2011 at 05:55 #

    Right on!

  11. discount eye exams July 23, 2011 at 04:28 #

    Many thanks for taking a few minutes to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and really like learning more about this topic. Whenever possible, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your blog with additional information?

  12. cheap eye exams July 23, 2011 at 12:48 #

    Many thanks for finding the time to talk about this, I feel strongly regarding it and love learning more about this topic. Whenever possible, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your blog site with more information?

  13. we are at war July 25, 2011 at 16:06 #

    You made a number of nice points there. I did a search on the theme and found the majority of people will consent with your blog.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: